Transfer from manual to automatic control in automatic control systems



May 18, 1954 A. M ILHENNY 2,679,022

TRANSFER FROM MANUAL TO AUTOMATIC CONTROL IN AUTOMATIC CONTROL SYSTEMS Filed Nov. 13, 1951 5 Sheets-Sheet l IN VEN TOR. ARCHIBALD MC ILHENNY 40M Mu KILL ATTORNEYS May 18. 1954 A. M ILHENNY TRANSFER FROM MANUAL TO AUTOMATIC CONTROL IN AUTOMATIC CONTROL SYSTEMS 5 Sheets-Sheet 2 Filed NOV. 13, 1951 Reverser Reverser Y N .N m% mu EC M m D L A m w R A ATTORNEYS A. M ILHENNY TRANSFER FROM MANUAL T0 AUTOMATIC CONTROL May 18. 1954 IN AUTOMATIC CONTROL SYSTEMS 5 Sheets-Sheet 5 Filed Nov. 13, 1951 INVENTOR. ARCHIBALD MC ILHENNY ATTORNEYS May 18, 1954 MCILHENNY 2,679,022

TRANSFER FROM MANUAL TO AUTOMATIC CONTROL IN AUTOMATIC CONTROL SYSTEMS I Filed Nov. 13, 1951 5 Sheets-Sheet 4 IN VEN TOR. ARC-HIBALD MC ILHENNY WWW/Moi ATTORN EYS May 18. 1954 A. MGILHENNY 2,679,022

TRANSFER FROM MANUAL TO AUTOMATIC CONTROL IN AUTOMATIC CONTROL SYSTEMS Filed Nov. 13, 1951 5 SheetsSheet 5 INVENTOR. I ARGHIBALD MclLHENNY ATTORNEYS Patented May 18, 1954 TRANSFER FROM MANUAL TO AUTOMATIC CONTROL IN AUTOMATIC CONTROL SYS- TEMS Archibald Mcllhenny, Willow Grove, Pa., assignor to Leeds and Northrup Company, Philadelphia, Pa., a corporation of Pennsylvania Application November 13, 1951, Serial No. 256,003

17 Claims. 1

This invention relates to automatic control systems of the type used for controllin the magnitude of a variable quantity or condition such as temperature, pH values, rate of flow or other physical, chemical, or electrical conditions or characteristics and having a storage element providing a time-function control and has for an object the provision of methods and apparatus for transferring from manual to automatic control at any point within the control range without introduction of a transitory control effect due to the transfer.

The present invention is applicable to balanceable control systems of the automatic type Whether operative by pneumatic or electrical means which includes storage capacity means for modifying the operation of the control system in accordance with a time function of the departure of the condition or characteristic under control from the control point. Such a storage capacity means may be utilized in a balanceable control system for the introduction of automatic reset control action. or automatic rate control action either of which in conjunction with a proportional mode of control produces a control action varying as a time function of the departure of the condition from the control point. Where the storage capacity means is used for introducing reset control action, the time function is an integral time function of the departure of the condition, but where the capacity means is used for rat action, the time function is a derivative time function of the departure. It is Well understood in the automatic control art that either a rate control action or a reset control action may be used alone with a proportional mode of control or both rate and reset control actions may be used together with the proportional control action. While reset and rate control actions are highly desirable in automatic control systerms of the balanoeable type, the storage capacity means used to introduce such action, prior to the present invention, has complicated the transfer from manual control to automatic control, by introducing a sudden change in the position of the condition-varying element, such as a valve controlling the flow of heat to a furnace. This sudden change in position is due solely tothe operation of transferring from manual to automatic control. Such movement of the valve is due to the fact that in the control of a process, such as a furnace or the like, manual control of the condition-varying means is most frequently desired at the time when the condition under control has deviated from the desired predetermined value,

generally referred to by those skilled in the art as the control point. Upon attempting to return to automatic operation of the control system while the condition is away from the control point, it has been found that the condition-com trolling or varying element may be caused to move solely due to the transfer. Such a sudden change in the condition-varying element may and sometimes does upset the system so that a substantial time may be required before smooth control is reestablished.

While previously proposed systems of automatic control have provided means for transferring from automatic to manual operation with little or no disturbance of the. process under control even though the controlled condition be away from the control point, the transfer from manual or automatic means could only be made either with the controlled characteristic or condition at the control point or after complicated manipulation of various controller elements if it were desired to avoid disturbances of the process under control. Such manipulations require the operator of the process to have special training so that he can understand the effects of each adjustment upon the system. This requirement is primarily due to the fact that storage capacity means are used for introducing a time function of the departure of the controlled condition from the control point automatically into the control signal. A control signal responsive means, such as an amplifier and an electric motor, or a diaphragm element for operating a valve in a pneumatic system is then controlled by the control signal which has present therein a quantity representative of that time function of the departure. While recognising the necessity for accounting for these time functions in transferring from manual to automatic control at other than the control point, other control systems of the type herein referred to require additional manipulation of the automatic control means to equate the automatically applied signal introduced by said control means to the signal being applied manually. Such systems require adjustment of the automatic signal prior to the time that transfer from manual to automatic can be made to prevent undue disturbance of the final control element.

In carrying out the present invention, there is provided means for transferring control of the condition-varying element from a manual control means to a signal-responsive means which includes means for continuously and simultaneously applying to the storage capacity means a control quantity variable in accordance with the deviation of the characteristic under control from a control point and another control quantity variable in accordance with the movement of the condition-varying element while under control of th manual control means.

In a preferred form of the invention, there is provided a balanceable control system of the electrical type including a first network having a circuit element, such as a slidewire, adjustable in accordance with the magnitude of the condition under control to produce an electrical signal and a second electrical network including an adjustable circuit element, such as another slidewire, adjustable in response to movement of a conditionwarying means, such as a valve. Said second electrical network includes therein a reset resistor, a reset capacitor, a rate capacitor and a rate resistor. Provision is made for corn necting the output of the networks and the signals developed therein in series circuit with signal responsive means, such as an amplifier and a motor, for automatically controlling the operation of said condition-varying means. Further in accordance with the invention circuit controller means are provided for preventing operation of the signal responsive means and for connecting rate capacitor and rc-et re-- sistor directly across the output term. ..-ls of the first network. In this way, the rate capacitor has applied thereto during manual control of the final control element, or varying means, a voltage signal produced the first network corresponding to the deviation of the controlled condition from the control point. Similarly, the reset capacitor has a voltage Signal applied thereto which is the algebraic sum of the voltages corresponding to said deviation and the position of the final control element. Upon return of the circuit controller to its original position for automatic control of the condition-varying means, the charge on said rate and reset capacitors produces a signal equal and opposite to the signal of said first network to prevent immediate adjustment of the conditioncontrolling means.

For further objects and advantages of the invention and for a detailed description of further novel features, reference is to be had to the following description taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings in which:

Fig. 1 diagrammatically illustrates a system including one form of apparatus to which the invention has been applied;

Fig. l.--A. diagrammatically illustrates a simplified form of the control system illustrated in Fig. l with the balanceable control system connected for automatic control of a final control element;

Fig. 1-13 is a diagrammatic illustration similar to Fig. l-A. with the control system connected for manual control of a final control element;

Fig. 2 is a fragmentary diagram of a simplified form of a control system useful in the understanding of the operation of Fig.1 and illustrating application of the present invention to a balanceable control system including electrostatic storage capacity means for introducing areset control action;

Fig. 3 is a fragmentary diagram similar to Fig. 2 useful in understanding the operation of Fig. l and illustrating the application of the present invention to a balanceable control system wherein rate control action is introduced;

Fig. i is a diagrammatic illustration or another condition-controlling system to which the invention is applicable; and

Fig. 5 diagrammatically illustrates the application of the present invention to a balanceable control system of the pneumatic type.

Referring to Fig. 1, the invention has been shown as applied to a balanceable control system of the electrical type which is arranged to control the superheat emperature of steam generated in a furnace H The superheat temperature of steam generated by furnace H3 is to be taken as representative of any measured variable, condition or characteristic, the magnitude of which is to be controlled either by automatic or manual means. As shown, the measured variable is the temperature of the superheated steam flowing in line [I as measured by thermocouple The temperature of the superheated steam in line I! is varied by changing the position of a condition-varying element, the damper !3, pro 'vided for controlling the quantity of not combustion gases passing through. the furnace stack It in heat-exchange relationship with a superheater coil l5. As shown, furnace IB includes a fire box 5 5, a boiler section ii and a fuel economizer it. In control of the temperature and pressure of steam delivered by way of line II, it is well understood by those skilled in the art that upon a decrease in temperature, as measured by thermocouple [2, there will be required increased flow of combustion gases generated in fire box it over coil [5. While the control of the rate of flow of fuel and combustion air to furnace it may be controlled, by other suitable means, upon a decrease of heat supplied to the super-heater coil I5, it is necessary that the damper :3 be adjusted to maintain the temperature of superheated steam from coil l5 substantially constant. Accordingly, the damper I3 is so adjusted that the percentage of the volume of combustion gases flowing through the superheater section of the furnace stack 84 is adjusted to compensate for any increase or decrease in the total volume of furnace gases supplied by furnace Hi. When the oonditiomvarying element, damper i3, is under automatic control, said element is automatically moved in a direction to return the measured variable or variable condition, temperature, to a predetermined magnitude.

As shown, the temperature of the superheated steam in line H is measured by means of thermocouple .22 which is connected to a suitable measuring circuit which includes a galvanometer Is and a balanceable network it having a slidewire 2! and a variable contact Zia relatively positionable in a direction to balance the thermocouple voltage. Such balance is achieved by means of a mechanical relay MR mechanically coupled to galvanometer it. While any suitable measuring arrangement may be utilized, the system illustrated is of the type disclosed in Squibb Patent No. 1,935,732. With an arrangement of the type shown in the Squibb patent, a change in the temperature of line II causes a deflection of galvanometer (9 which in turn actuates mechanical relay ME, to adjust the position between slidewire '2] and contact 2 la to restore balance of measuring network 20. Simultaneously mechanical relay MR may actuate a recording and indicating means 22 to provide an indication on scale 23 and a record on chart 24. Chart 24 is driven by a synchronous motor 25 energized from any suitable source.

Simultaneously with movement of movable contact 2m in response to changes in temperature of the superheater line I l, provision is made for moving an adjustable circuit element 26 with respect to a slidewire 21 in an electrical network designated generally as control network 28. Control network 28 is interconnected with a second control network 29 by way of line 30 and together networks 28 and 29 form a balanceable control system having an output circuit provided by way of lines 3! and which are connected to the input terminals or" an amplifier 33, preferably of the high impedance, high gain type. Amplifier means 33 together with motor 34 whose direction of rotation is controlled by amplifier as by way of forward and reverse relays 3-5 and 36 form a responsive means to which there is applied the control signals developed by unbalance between control networks 23 and 29 to vary the position of damper l3 in the furnace Hi. This responsive means operates to move said damper in a direction to maintain the magnitude of the temperature in line H at a predetermined value and to reduce the control signals to substantially zero, thereby balancing the output of control networks 25 and 29.

With reference to network 28, it will be observed that control slidewire 2'! is connected through a resistor 3! to a source of power, shown as battery 38. There is likewise connected in parallel with slidewire 2'! a branch circuit including resistors 39 and 40 and a slidewire 4!. One or both of the resistors 39 and all may be omitted if desired. As shown, line 32 which serves to connect one input terminal of the amplifier 33 and one output terminal of network 28 is connected to a movable contact 42 cooperating with slidewire M Thus, it will be seen that upon adjustment of contact 26 with respect to control slidewire 21, a voltage E1 is developed between conductors or lines so and 32 since these lines are connected to the movable contacts 26 and 42 on slidewires 2! and 4 l respectively. As the relativeposition of contact 32 on slidewire M for bridge balance determines the position of contact 26 relative to slidewire 2'1, contact 42 may be used to determine the control point of the system.

With reference to slidewire such as 2!, 2'! and 4|, it is possible in practice either to make the associated contacts Zia, 2t and 42 movable with respect to the slidewire or to make the slidewires movable with respect to the contact. However, for simplicity and uniformity in the wiring diagram, each contact associated with the slidewire resistors of the networks has been illustrated as adjustable.

In order to make the control system including networks 28 and 2S balaneeable, that is, so that the signal appearing at the input terminals of amplifier 33 is substantially zero, provision is made for motor "i l to drive a movable contact 43 with respect to a slidewire 44 connected in the second control network 25. As shown, slidewire 44 is connected to a source of power, such as battery 45, by way of a resistor at. There is likewise connected in parallel with slidewire M a voltagadividing circuit including resistors All! and 48, to the common junction of which there is connected a line cs. As is well understood by those skilled in the art, it line .9 were connected di rectly to the other input terminal of amplifier 33, by way of line 50 connected thereto, networks 25 and 29 forming a balanceable control system would provide a proportional control action.

' That is to say, for a given adjustment of contact 25 with respect to control slidewire 21, by mechanical relay MR, there would be a corresponding follow-up adjustment of motor 34 to move damper l3 and contact 43 with respect to the slidewire t4. If the voltages across slidewires 21 and M are equal, a given angular movement of contact 2% would produce an equal angular adjustment of contact 433. Mathematically, for a given change in the variable condition or characteristic, 0, the adjustment of slidewire contact 53 and damper is will be equal to K10 where K1 is the proportional action constant. In order to provide adjustment of t .e proportionality, slidewire resistors 5i and 52 respectively are connected in parallel with slidewires 21 and 44. If then resistor 55 is set to make the voltage across slidewire 2i greater than that across slidewire as, a greater relative movement of contact 43 with respect to slidewire 44 would be required to produce a voltage E2 between line 49 and line as equal to the changed value of voltage E1 between lines so and 32. The adjustment of either resistor 5% or 52 is referred to as throttling range or proportional band adjustment. In practice, resistors 51 and 52 be mechanically linked for simultaneous adjustment in opposite directions so that movement of the movable arms will produce maximum change in the proportional band.

In balanceable control systems of the type shown in Fig. 1, there is introduced a reset control action by means of a reset resistor including a fixed resistance 55 and a variable resistance 58 connected to line 39 and to movable contact :3 through a slidewire 5? whose function will be ascribed in detail hereinafter. In addition to the reset resistor provided by resistance sections 55 and a reset capacitor is connected between line d9 leading to the common junction between resistors 47 and 38 and the opposite end of the reset resistor. Capacitor 58, resistor 55 and slidewire resistor .35 introduce a correction for droop resulting from changes in load conditions on the process under control where the mode of control includes only proportional action. Such correction is introduced to maintain the magnitude of the condition or the variable characteristic at a predetermined value notwithstanding changes in load on the controlled condition. This correction is referred to by those skilled in the art as reset or droop-corrective action, meaning a corrective action which prevents permanent decrease in the variable characteristic with rising load. Mathematically, the reset action may be expressed as a correction of magnitude corresponding with the summation with respect to time of the deviation of the condition from a predetermined value. The action is equal to K fodt where K2 is a constant and (ii is the time differential increment.

In further explanation of such reset action plus proportional action, reference may be had to Fig. 2 wherein similar numbers have been used to identify elements similar in function to those illustrated in Fig. 1. However, the system of Fig. 2 has been re resented as having potentiometer circuits 28a and 29a replacing the bridge networks 28 and 29. As shown the potentiometer circuit 23a includes a potentiometer Na and a movable contact 28a. The contact 25a is movable in response to a change in the condition under control, such as temperature as measured by thermocouple it so that a voltage E1 is produced variable in accordance with the condition under control. The network 29 of Fig. 1, in Fig. 2 represented by potentiometer circuit includes a slidewire i le and movable contact 43c Whose position along the slidewire is controlled in accordanoe with the position of the final control element, re resented as valve 5%. Valve i3a is movable in r spouse to the s a1 responsive means, includin amplifier and motor 3d. The control point in the schematic system shown in Fig. 2 corresponds with the lower end of slidewire Zia.

By reason of capacitor bein slidewire resistor roots 5! move movable contact lilo at the voltage resistors 56; equal to the voltage E1 between conduc ors 3 In order to so maintain the across resistors and til, it ret nred that there be a constant current 'ing through them. However, by reason of capacitor 3 ,ing in circuit with net-- work 2330., movement contact lea must produce a gradually inc voltage ac oss resistors and 5t to maintain a constant current flow, since capacitor 53 gradually accumulates a charge result in an increase in potential it, due to the our flow therethrough. In consequence. the motor 34. wi l be progressively energized to i ove contact 5354 along slidewire did to Thus, motor 36 will. be operated so long as there is departure from the value of the controlled condition from its predetermined value, generally referred to the control point. Accordingly, adjustment motor valve contact 43a will be in accordance with the sum of first, the deviation of the condition from the control point, and, second, the time slur lion of the deviation of the variable condition ho n the control point. However, it is to be emphasised that whenever motor t l moves contact M relative to slidewire itle to position required for balance, that is, when the voltage across resistances and 5B is equal to the voltage E1 between conductors 3t and the motor will be deenergized since the input signal will be substantially zero. The control action is generally by series of steps or intermittent operations of the control. motor 3 1 to produce an average resultant rate or". motion proportional to the deviation of the controlled variable from the control point.

men ioned above, the introduction of reset control action in the system. shown in Fig. 1, is highly desirable the operation of motor 34 and damper is with automatic control thereof. However, when is to control the position or" motor and 53' by manual means, such as by push button switc cs 53 and 5 such manual control, due to the mechanical linkage between motor Eli contact [2-3, will introduce a voltage reset resistors and 55, which in turn will place a charge on reset capacitor 58, dependent upon the position of the final control element. Upon return of. the control from manmeans to automatic means including ampliiier and the bulanceable control system, there introduced a control signal of magnitude dependent upon the amount the condition under co; trol is away from its control point. Such a signal 0.1? course, cause motor 3 to operate immediately in a direction to reduce that signal, hence, there is caused movement of motor 34 and damper it by transferring control from manual to automatic means unless that transfer be made at a point wh re the controlled condition is at its predetermined value.

It is well understood in the control system art that the automatic controller is tuned by adjustment of the proportional action and the reset action so that the condition under control will be returned to the control point as rapidly as possible without undue oscillation. Under these conditions, the sudden introduction of a spurious control signal, as described above, may introduce wide and undesirable oscillation of the controlled variable about the control point.

In accordance with the present invention, means are provided for preventing undesirable oscillation of the controlled variable by preconditioning the balanceable control system so that it will be balanced at the time of transfer from manual to automatic control, irrespective of the magnitude of the condition under control. For this purpose, a circuit-controller, designated generally as Gil, Fig. 1, includes a switch Bl, Figs. 1 for interconnecting lines 32 and 59 during such time as the condition-varying element is under manual control by push button switches and Fig. 1. In this way there is during manual control continuously applied to storage capacity means 53 the algebraic sum of signals E1 and E2.

Reference is again made to Fig. 2 wherein the operation of a control system including only proportional action and reset action is particularly shown. If valve lac be moved from the illustrated position as above described, voltage E2 will be developed between contact 43a and line Sid from potentiometer resistor Ma. Upon manual control of valve Ha switch BI is closed to bypass high impedance amplifier 33 and to apply between conductors 353 and 59 voltage E1. If voltage be different from E2, the capacitor 58 will acquire a charge equal to the difference belen voltages. However, upon opening the switching iii to return the system to automatic control, the algebraic sum of the voltage due to the charge acquired by capacitor 58 and voltage 112 will always be equal to voltage E1 which existed at the time of opening of switch 5 1. Accordingly, whenever switch ii! is opened to return the sys tem from manual to automatic control, the difference voltage applied to the amplifier 33 is substantially zero. Therefore, valve 130. is not immediately moved and there is achieved transfor from manual to automatic control at any point within the control range without introduction of transitory control effects due to the transfer. However, after transfer to automatic control, the reset control action normally introduced by resistors 55 and 5e and capacitor 58 will produce a position-ohange of valve l3a dependent upon the time deviation of the controlled variable from the control point.

In the system of Fig. 1, there is also provided rate control action, that is to say, an adjustment of damper i3 by motor 34 is made in accordance with the rate of change of the variable condition. Such action is introduced by means of slidewire resistor 62 and capacitor 63.

Mathematically, the rate control action may be expressed by saying that there is provided a component in the adjustment of damper 13 equal to d0 1(3 d t where K3 is a constant. This circuit likewise includes a slidewire resistance 64 and a. fixed resistance 65. As indicated, slidewire resistances c2 and 54 may be mechanically coupled for dual adjustment by means of knob 66 in accordance with the system disclosed in application Serial 9 No. 149,775, filed March 15, 1950 by Elwood T. Davis, a coemployee, issued January 12., 1954 as, U. S. Patent No. 2,666,170. As. shown, resistor 82 is in series with the input terminal of amplifier 33 connected by way of line 59 through line SI and the right-hand contact 61a of switch means E3? of circuit-controller so. As thus connected, the input signal through line 50 is attenuated so that the voltage produced across resistors 55. and 55 must be made greater by an amount equal to that attenuation in order to produce across conductors 38, 3|, a signal voltage equal to the voltage E1. As explained in said application, the relative movement of contact 63 on slidewire 44 will include a component due to the rate of change of the variable condition under control.

In brief, as contact 43 is moved by motor 34 in response to a continuous change in the controlled variable, a voltage is developed between lines 36 and 59a. This results in a flow of charging current through slidewire resistor 62, slidewire. resistor fi l, and resistor 65 to capacitor 63.. Since there will be a voltage drop in slidewire resistor '82, the movement of contact d3 will be advanced by an amount relative to the deviation rom the control point needed to overcome the attenuation due to slidewire resistor 62 in order that the voltage between conductors 3i and 30 shall be equal and opposite to the voltage between conductors 3i} and 32. If the controlled variable be rapidly changing, then the contact 43 will be rapidly moved. The rate of change of voltage will, therefore, be increased and with the increased rate of change of voltage there will be an increased current flow through slidewire resistor 52 to increase the attenuation and to increase the movement of contact 53 in order to achieve balance. Hence, the effect of resistor 62 and of the branch including the capacitor 63 is to cause an additional movement of damper l3 and contact as in accordance with the rate of change of the controlled variable.

If upon transfer from manual to automatic, the controlled variable be away from the control point, there will be present a difference voltage which will applied in toto to the amplifier 33 a step function) to produce rapid movement of contact 33. A step function even of small magnitude will, due to the rate action introduced by resistor 52 and capacitor 63, cause the motor 34 to operate the damper I3 either to fully opened or fully closed position.

To prevent this undesired action, a third switch means 58 is provided in circuit-controller til so that voltage E1 is applied directly across rate capacitor 63 during such time as the condition-varying element is under manual control. As shown, switch means 65 provides a connection between line as and the junction between fixed resistor 65 and capacity means 63 by way of conductor t9 connected thereto.

It will be noted that for automatic operation of the control system, switch means 61 provides a connection through contact 61a between line all, connected to one input terminal of amplifier 33, and line 3 5, connected to the junction between resistors E2 and at. Contact Bib of switch 61 serves to short-circuit the input terminals of amplifier 33 by connecting line at to line 32 when circuit-controller (it is to the left, as seen in Fig. 1, for manual operation of the final control element.

In Fig, there is illustrated the applicability of the present invention to a system incorporating only rate action inaddition to proportional con l0 trol action. However, in the system of Fig. 3, there is included a pair of switch means, for example switches E'lsc and 58a. In this arrangement switch 5148 provides a connection around amplifier 33 for both shorting the amplifier and supplying the voltage E1 from network to line However, a distinguished from the embodi- 113111} of Fig. 1, provision made for only shortcircuiting resistors es and while variable resistor is retained in the series circuit network c inected to control network. By this ar- .Ck moment it will be observed that when the cir- -lWCGILlZI'O113l means is moved so that switches are closed, the voltage E1 i applied tamed t roughout the time that the final control is being manipulated by manual means. in the simplified iorm shown in Fig. 3, the final control element is illustrated as a valve 13a in a fiow line heat to modify the temperature of thermocouple 52. Upon return to autoio control of valve its, and in response to am.- or 33 and motor 34, the voltage across capacitor E3 initially will be equal to the voltage E1, corresponding to the controlled variable. Resistors may attenuate the voltage from capacitor 53 so that the voltage E3 appearing between conductors 3i! and 3! difier slightly from the voltage E1. The difference in voltages and E2 is applied to the input terminals of amy er 23 and causes motor 3 to adjust the position of valve Lia and the position of contact 63a on. st- .ewire t l-5a. The adjustment of contact 43a will be to extent to restore the proportional rela nship between the value of the controlled condition and the position of the final control element.

l'lowevcr, since the voltage produced by the charge on capacitor 53 at the time of transfer is equal to voltage E1, immediately after the transfer and upon the instant of opening of switch 51:1: the voltage across capacitor =33 is equal and opposite to voltage E1. At the instant of transfer, including the openingof sv. t-v Sta, any diiference in voltage between that across capacitor 53 and between contact sea. and conductor 3&3 divides slidewirc resistor and the combined resistance of slidewire resistor 6% and resistor 55. The movement of contact ite is in a direction to reduce the voltage difierence. The action is rapid and capacitor lit loses very little of its charge before voltage balance is reestablished with E3 equal to E1. In this manner there is avoided any substantial disturbance of the system due to rate action upon operation of the transfer switch from manual to automatic.

Referring now to the control circuit for motor 3d, Fig, 1-, it will be seen that relay and 35 may be selectively connected. to a source of power, such as transformer it, either by amplifier 33v or push-button switch means as and 53. As shown, the relays have one side of t eir coils connected to the opposite ends of the secondary winding of transformer it, while the center tap is connected to the amplifier and the contact of switches 53 and Relays and 38 in turn control switch means ll and T2 to connect relays l3 and i l respectively across direct-current power lines, designated as L+ and L. Motor 34 is preferably of the shunt-connected type having a field winding, designated generally as '15, connected directly between lines L+ and L so that the direction of rotation of motor 35 i dependent upon the polarity of the directscurrent energy supplied to brushes it and ill connected to the armature of motor 3 5. As illustrated, relay i4 is provided with a pair of contacts Ma and "14b which are arranged to connect brushes T5 and I? to lines L and L+, respectively, through contacts bio and 2% of limit switch ill, operable by cam "I8 which is mechanically coupled to motor 34. This circuit may be traced from L+ to L through line i It, contact Mb, conductor ill, contact S'Ib, conductors IE2 and H9, brush If, the armature of motor at, brush it, conductor M3, contact tile, conductor l M, contact Ma, conductor I I 5 and resister til to line L.

For rotation of motor 534 in the other direction, relay "it by means of contacts its and lfib is arranged to connect brush id to line L+ and brush H to line L. The connections to lines 11+ and L are made by way or" contacts 79c and lab of limit switch l9 which is operable in response to the position of cam lit", mechanically coupled to motor 3 t. This circuit may be traced from ill-ithrough conductor lib, contact Ilia, conductor Ill, contact 19a, conductors H8 and H3, brush It, the armature of motor 3'3, brush Tl, conductor II, contact lPJb, conductor ltd, contact 73b and resistor 85? to line L. It will be observed that the connection of the armature of motor 3 1 to line L- for rotation in either direction is made through a current-limiting resistor Bil.

The position of the final control element, damper it, may be indicated by a meter, such as voltmeter 8%, connected to a movable or adjustable contact 32 variable in position along a slidewire 83 in response to movement of motor 36 and damper it. As shown, slidewire 83 may be connected directly between lines L l- L through an adjustable voltage-dropping resistor a l. It will be apparent to those skilled in the art that the voltage across meter 8|! may be made to vary in accordance with the position of damper 153 so that the indicating scale on meter iii may be calibrated in accordance with that position. The calibration of meter be made by adjustment of resistor As mentioned hereinbefore the connection between adjustable contact 43 and slidewire resistor 55 is made through a slidewire 51 and a movable contact 51a. In the embodiment of Fig. l, slidewire 5'! is provided to introduce a further electrical control signal or quantity representative of another variable condition. In the present arrangement, the flow of combustion air in fire box l6 may be taken as the other variable condition. The flow of combustion air is measured by draft tubes 90 and 9| connected to a tilting U-tube manometer 92 mounted upon a lever arm 93 supported for rotation upon a pivot 94. By reason of the difference in pressure detected by tubes 99 and 9| the fluid, such as mercury, in U-tube 92 is caused to assume a difference in elevation in the two legs of the tube, as illustrated. Lever arm 93 positions a core member 95 mounted adjacent the outer end thereof with respect to a primary coil St and a pair of secondary coils 531a and 912:. Primary coil 96 may be connected to a suitable source of alternating current so that secondary windings 91a and 91b are energized in accordance with the flux linkage between the primary and secondary coils by movable core 95. The position of core member 95 effectively controls the flux and the magnitude of voltage produced in each of the secondary windings 91a and 911). Full wave rectifiers 98 and 99 are respectively connected to secondary windings 91a and 91b. The alternating voltage developed in each of the coils may be converted to a direct-current signal by rectifiers 98 and 99 and applied to voltage-dividing re-' sistors I00 and I OI so that there is provided a direct-current signal between lines I02 and I03 whose magnitude and sense is determined by the position of core 95 in accordance with the difference in pressure between draft tubes and 9|. While the full direct-current signal between lines I02 and IE3 may be introduced into the resistance-capacitance network including the reset resistors 55 and 56 and capacitor 58, along with the output of control network 23, provision is made by movable contact 51a to introduce any desired portion of this additional control signal, from zero to the full potential difference appearing across slldewire 51. The foregoing circuit is illustrative of numerous modifications of other balanceable control systems which may be utilized in connection with the present invention. However, the introduction, or exclusion, of such additional control signals forms no part of the present invention, systems of this type being described and claimed in a copending application, filed February 14, 1952, Serial No. 271,486, which is a continuation-in-part of Serial Nos. 149,775 and 256,070, of Elwood '1. Davis, a coemployee.

Reference is now made to Figs. l-A and 1-3, wherein there is illustrated a further simplified form of the apparatus shown in Fig. I, useful in understanding the operation of the system of Fig. 1 since the positions of circuit-controller switches BI, 61 and 68 have been rearranged in Figs. l-A and l-B to identify more clearly their functions in the operation of transferring from manual to automatic control of the conditionvarying element, damper I3, without upset of the automatic control system and the switches are shown in different circuit-controlling positions. In Fig. l-A, the circuit-controller switches are connected for automatic control of the final control element by the responsive means including amplifier 33 and motor 34. In order to simplify further the explanation of the operation of the system of Fig. 1, the reset resistor has been identified as a variable resistor 56a and the rate resistor has been illustrated as variable resistor 62a.

In accordance with the present invention, switches SI, 57 and 68 have been provided which may be operated to the position shown in Fig. 1-3 during manual control of the final control element so that transfer from manual to automatic control may be made at any point within the throttling range or proportional band without bump, i. e. a sudden movement of the condition-varying element due solely to the transfer. As particularly shown in Fig. 1-28, the signal generated by network 28 which is representative of the condition or characteristic under control is continuously applied across reset resistor 56a and rate capacitor 63 and at the same time the algebraic sum of the control signals produced by networks 28 and 29 is applied to reset capacitor means 58. By these circuit provisions, when the switch contacts are restored to their automatic position as shown in Fig. l-A, there is established between lines 30 and SI by capacitor 83 a voltage equal and opposite to the voltage between lines 30 and 32 to produce a difference voltage therebetween of substantially zero. That difference voltage, the input voltage to amplifier 33 being substantially zero, no abrupt motion will be produced by motor 34 until such action is produced by the automatic control means in response to deviation of the condition under control from the set point or control point. Hence there is achieved bumpless transfer of the control element from manual to automatic control at any point within the throttling range.

As mentioned hereinbefore, the present invention may be utilized in systems incorporating both "eset and rate control actions with proportional control action as in Fig. 1. However, as shown in Fig. 2, the invention is likewise applicable to a system incorporating only reset control and proportional control actions by providing a single circuit-controlling switch for simultaneously short-circuiting the input to amplifier 33 and applying the voltage E1 generated in network 28a to reset capacitor 58 and reset resistors 55 and 56 as described hereinabove. Likewise the present invention is applicable to eliminate undesired transitory movement of a final control element in a control system incorporatlng only rate and proportional control actions as shown in Fig. 3 and described hereinbefore.

Reference is now inacle to the embodiment of the invention illustrated in Fig. 4. As there shown, the condition under control is the temperature of furnace H6 to which heat is supplied by way of pipe I ll whose flow is controlled by final control element, valve H2. In this arrangement the thermocouple I2 is positioned furnace iii and is interconnected to the measuring bridge network 2d of the same type as that shown in Fig. 1. Similar reference characters are used in the description of Fig. 4 as those in Fig. l wherever the elements and functions are identical to those in the arrangement of Fig. 1.

It will be observed that the principal differenoe in the arrangement of Fig. 4 from that described in connection with Fig. 1 is in the manual control arrangement for positioninz final control element, valve H2. In the present embodiment, slidewire H3 is connected in parallel with slidewire id. A movable contact H 3 adjustable by means of knob lit is connected to a conductor lit. Conductor H6 in turn is com nected to contact l lib of switch l H which forms a part or circuit-controller iii! so that when circuit-controller means til is moved to the manual position, i. e. to the left as seen in Fig. 4, one input terminal of amplifier 33 is connected to conductor lit through contact Ilsa of switch ilil of readwalve switch lZl, also designated as RV. At the same time, the other input ternii nal of amplifier 33 is connected to line to through contact l iQo of switch means H9 of read-valve EV and contact 62th of switch me which likewise forms a part of the circuit-controller means and is operable therewith. Accordingly, it will be seen that the output of amplifier 33 is arranged to be controlled either automatically or manually, dependent upon the position of circuit-controller means 50.

With circuit-controller Ell positioned to the left for manual control of amplifier 33, motor till it, there is provided a simple and valve ti bridge network including slidewires is and H3 which applies through conductors H6 and so the unbalanced voltage thereof to amplifier 33. This unbalanced voltage will provide a manually adjustable proportional mode of control since adjustable contact 43' is moved in conjunction with movements of motor 121 and valve H2. In other words, the position assumed by motor I2! lo and valve l l2 will be made to correspond within the capabilities of a proportional mode control to the position of adjustable contact 5 M on slidewire M3.

Ucntrol of motor i2! by amplifier 33 in the arrangement of Fig. 4 is produced in a manner somewhat similar to that shown in Fig. 1, except that motor IZi in the present arrangement is of the alternating-current type. ihe direction of rotation of motor it! is dependent upon the energization of coils E22 and i223 under control of relays 35 and 36 which are connected to a transformer lit in manner similar to that described in 1. When the polarity of the input signal, whether due to automatically or manually applied input potent als appears across the input terminals of amplifier it, one of the relays "Jill be energized, for example, relay 35, to connect motor winding it? between alternating current supply lines and L-l by way or" con ductor contact i of relay conductor are, contacts lila of read-valve switch till, contacts its-a of a limit switch ifis to one side of winding in and thus to the other supply line ii -2. At the same time winding i223 is energized from line L-l through capacitor 558 to supply the necessary field of another phase.

When the input signal to amplifier 33 is of polarity to energize relay to connect motor winding :23 to supply line L-i, such connection is made by way of conductor i2 3, contact lie of relay 35, contact E38 of relay 35, conductor ESE, contacts it'll; or switch iii, contacts iQlZa f limit switch it? to one side of winding E23, while the other side of that winding is connected directly to line L-z'l. in manner similar to that mentioned above, motor winding $22 is energized from line L-l through capacitor i558. Associated with the relays and 35 are signal lights H3 and l-id which as indicated are normally onergized. The signal light it? is energized through a circuit which may be traced from line L-l by way or" signal light E33, conductors i353 and E25, contacts lilo. and italic, motor winding 52?: to the other line L--2. The circuit thus traced is of lower resistance than that provided between light 33 and Til--22 by way of re sistor [35.

The other signal light ltd is normally energized by way of a circuit which may be traced from line L-i by way of light ltd, conductors l3? and Hi, contacts it'll; and E3254, motor winding are and the other supply line The circuit traced is or" lower resistance than that provided through resistor [35%. Both lights are normally energized to indicate that the control system is functioning within its throttling range, i. c. with the valve H2 short of its maximum open position and short of its fully closed position. When the valve H2 is moved to one limit or the other whether that be a fully closed or a fully open position, cams its and will mechanically connected wit motor lili and valve iii? car" to open limit switches E32 and 523, respectii -J, at

When relay 35 is energized it not only closes a circuit to energize motor winding iEZi as described above, but it also completes a short circuit around signal light I34 thereby extinguishing it. Thus, there is provided visual indication of the energization of the motor for rotation in one direction. Similarly, the closure of the motor circuit by relay means 36 extinguishes the signal light I33 to indicate visually the opposite rotation of motor 2L in a condition of oscillation, i. c. with motor I2! being energized for rotation first in one direction and then in the other, the relays and 3% will be operated rapidly between open and closed positions causing lights I33 and H54 to blink. The alternate flashing of these lights indicates the presence of oscillation in the system which ordinarily can be suppressed by reducing the gain of amplifier 33 by a suitable gain control provided therefor. Blinking of only one light indicates normal automatic control of the operation of motor (2|.

With the automatic-manual circuit-controller means E in the position shown in Fig. l, prcvision is made for determining the position of the final control element valve H2. Such indication is desirable particularly when the valve remotely located from the control system. To accomplish this determination of valve position the read-valve switch i2? is operated to throw switches HE and lit to the left of the position shown in Fig. 4. Such operation of switch til causes contacts Mia and iZ'lb to be opened to disable the motor windings i222 and :23 and simultaneously to connect the input terminals of amplifier 33 across lines it? and 38. The signal lights I33 and i341 at such time will be energised through the circuits including resistors i536 and I38, respectively. If the voltage or potential between line (it, which it will be remembered is connected to the valve-positioned contact and line I it is not zero, the amplifier will immediately energize one or the other of relays 35 and One of the signal lights it or 3 3 will tinguished by reason 01'' the short-circuit g action of one of the relays, thus indicating which relay has been energized. The contact ti l will then be adjusted along slidewire i it by manipulation of control knob Mil until the input to the amplifier is zero. When such input is zero, both of lights I33 and its will be energized, since both relays 35 and 36 are deenergized. By of a scale Hfia associated with slidewire lit the position of the contact .3 relative to slidewire 44 can be read upon scale 113a, thus giving an indication of the position oi" the valve-actuating mechanism and of the valve H2.

With the control system shown in Fig. 4, it will be apparent that the circuit-controller ill in ad-- dition to operating switch means ii"! and HG as discussed hereinabove to transfer control of amplifier means 33 from manual to automatic, and vice versa, also serves to operate switch means 5?, 6i and 68 to complete the circuit connections of the same type as those described in connection with Fig. 1. It will be remembered that switches El, (E1 and E3 provide circuit connections for applying voltage E1, developed from network 28, between lines 39 and. 32 directly across rate capacitor 83 and reset resistors 55 and 56. Simultaneously, the voltage E1 from network 28 and the voltage E2 generated in net work 29 in response to the variations in the position of the final control element are both applied to reset capacitor 58. Accordingly, it

It the system should be v will be seen that so long as control of motor [21 and valve H2 is by manual means including the adjustable arm Hi, there will be applied to the resistance-capacitance network E1, the volage generated in network 23. This R-C network is also connected to the network 29 and immediately upon return to automatic control, the signal at the input terminals of amplifier as will be substantially zero. Any departure from zero signal at the input to amplifier 33 after return of circuit controller 50 to the position shown in Fig. 4 will then be due entirely to normal automatic control action produced by the balanceable control system including networks 28 and 29 and the resistance-capacitance network associated with network 253.

Reference is now made to Fig. 5, wherein the invention has been shown as applied to a pneumatic control system of a type fully described in McLeod Patent 2,507,606. The system is shown as being applied to the control of the temperature in furnace 208. The temperature of furnace 260 is to be taken as representative of any measured variable, the magnitude of which is to be under either automatic or manual control. As shown, the measured variable, temperature, is controlled by changing the position of a condition-controlling element, such as the valve 20l, connected in a fuel supply line Zilia leading to furnace 2G6. Provision is made for opening valve 2!]! to any desired extent by means of a pneumatic operator, or actuator, M12 having a diaphragm 293 and an opposing spring 264. The,

temperature of the furnace is measured by means of a measuring circuit including a thermocouple suitably positioned in the furnace and electrically connected to a potentiometer network 2536 and a galvanometer coil 26?. While any suitable measuring arrangement may be utilized, that shown includes a mechanical relay 2% operable under the control of galvanometer 291, details of which will be found in the previously mentioned Squibb Patent No. 1,935,732. Upon change of the temperature of furnace 2%, the mechanical relay 283 adjusts the slidewire of the potentiometer network 2% to restore balance of the measuring network and through mechanical connection 209 and associated gearing 21!), adjusts the position of a baffle 2i 1 relative to a nozzle 2 I2 in a pilot unit 2 i3. The air pressure applied against diaphragm 2&3 is under the control of the pneumatic control system and varies with change of position of baffle 2 ll relative to nozzle 2!? in manner now to be described.

1 ered by way of a pipe 0' ure regulator passageway 21 e:

ices "'hin bellows connected by is bellows 2E2 forms or boster, 22! which also ire-clue s bellows iii three bellows mounted. between a stationary e and a able lower 2i, pivotaliy supported on the ase in. l. by ible hinge leaf spring A. sprn 2:25 is adjustable by means of a not i. to vary the force applied to te As fully explained in said l/lcLeod boos 22d serves to apply to an on score which is a magnification of the air pressure existing in pipe ha away from nozzle "2N2, there will be a decrease in pressure in pipe 228 a correspondingly greater decrease in the pressure in pipe 22'! and vice versa.

Associated with the baflle 2H is an arm 240 253 to nozzle ratio .final control element, valve pivoted at 24! and against which are disposed a reset bellows 2'42 and a proportional bellows 245. If only the bellows 243 were associated with lever 24H .therewould be present only a proportionalposition action, i. e. a control action which has a continuous linear relationship between the value of the controlled variableand the position of the However, by providing bellows 2 52 subjected to the same pressure as bellows 2:33, but through a restriction such as throttling va1 ve24li, there is eliminated the droop, or offset, which an inherent characteristic of any proportional-position controi system. The result of the reset action due to bellowsfi 'lfi is that valve. 2% will be automatically adjusted to overcome the droop or oiiset which would otherwise be present.

By, including a restriction,.such as throttling valve 245, in the connection between the proportional bellows 243 and line 22?, the negative feedback action on thebafiie 2 i l is attenuated during periods when the pressure in line 22? is undergoing change. This attenuation results in the introduction of rate action into the operation of the system for the same purpose as discussed in connection with the electrical systems disclosed anddescribed in Figs. 1 to 4.

Whenever the control systemis upset as by a change in thematerial processing requirements, it may be desirable to place the controlled variable ,under manual control. Accordingly, there is provided circuit ccntrolling meansv including valves 25%, 25!, 252 and 253;. Valves 251i, 25i, 252 and 253are, preferably of the on-off type. Si-

multaneous with the opening of valves 25d, 25!

and 252 to connect thecontrol-responsive means or penurnatic operator 202 for manual control, valve 253 is closed to prevent introduction of the automatically produced control signal pressure from line 22'! into actuator 2fi2. When valves 25H, 25! and 252 have been operated to their open position and valve 253 to its closed position, provision is made for operating actuator 2&2 by a manually, variable air pressure supplied. to the actuator 2G2 by way of line 255, throttling valve 256, valve 250 and lines 25'! and 258. It willbe apparent that the motion of thefinal control element, valve 20!, will be in accordance withthe pressure determined by the manual control means, valve 256.

In accordance with the present invention, provision is made for assuring that the pressure-rd sponsive means, actuator 282 has applied thereto the same pressure from line 22: asthat supplied from valve 256 when transfer is made from manual to automatic position by the operation of valve-actuating device 250a. To assure that the output pressure of the automatic control system delivered by booster 22! through line 221, is the same asthat applied to pipe 258 and actuator 292 by manually applied air pressure, there is supplied to the reset storage capacity including the reset bellows 242 and tank 259, a signal pressure representative of the manually supplied signal pressure andthe deviation of thecontrolled quantity from the control point. Such pressure is applied to the reset bellows 242 and tank 259 by line 26!], through valve 252 and line 26! which is interconnected with a nozzle 2B2, bellowsf2$3 and air supply line- I90 through throttling; valve 264. Nozzle 262,,bel1ows 263and throttlingvalve 264 form, a part of a pneumatic relay. ,2B5. The pressuredeveloped in line 26! is primarily under the control of nozzle 262 which is arranged to cooperate witha balanceable lever; 266 mounted for rotation about a pivotpoint 26?. The movement of lever 266 is controlled to maintain the pressure in line 26i at a value corresponding to the algebraic sum or the pressure applied manually and a pressure representative of the condition under control. The manually applied pressure is introduced into the balanceable system by bellows 268 through extension line 2%, while the control pressure representative of the condition under control is introduced by bellows its interconnected to another booster unititla, similar to booster unit 22!. Booster unit 22m is in turn connected to a pilot unit-2nd, similar to. pilot unit 213. However, pilot, unit'2i3a is provided with only a single bellows 2ll3a operating-against lever arm Edda to oppose the adjustment of baffle 21 !a in response .tomovement thereof by gearing Zifla operable by mechanical relay 208. It wiIl be noted that since there is no reset bellows provided in pilot unit 2 53a that the output of booster unit Ziiawill belproportional to the value of the condition under control, i. e. the temperature of furnace Ziiii. Relay ;265 accordingly provides a system for introducing a pressure to thesreset capacity means which is the algebraic sum of the pressures representative or the position ,of the final control element, VaIveZM, and the magnitude of the condition under control, since bellows 2% is responsive to the position of valve 2%! and bellows 2589 is responsive to the magnitude of the condition under control. Both bellows 258 and 2%9 are arranged to rotate lever arm 266 in a clockwise direction upon increase in pressures therein. Such increases in pressureof either bellows 268 or 289 will produce an increased pressure in .feedback bellows 2 63 movementoflever 268 closer to nozzle 262. This increase in pressure is likewise applied to the reset capacity means 262 when valve 252 is operated to the manual position.

During the time that the valve is being controlled manually, the pilot unit H3 and. booster 22! continue to function automatically to maintain the pressure across reset valve 244 of magnitude dependent'upon the deviation of the controlled condition from the control point. However, since the pressure on the reset capacity means is the sum of the deviation and of the manually controlled pressure applied to actuator 282, the pressure in line 22! is at all times during manual control equal to the manually controlled pressure on actuator 282. With the pressure in line 22'! the same as thatmanually applied to actuator 2132, there will be no movement of the valve 20!, due solely to the transfer from manual to automatic control means.

Accordingly, when itis desired .to return from manual to automatic control of pressure-responsive actuator 282, control knob 250a may be turned to the position shown Fig. 5 thereby closing valves 258,25! and 252 and reopening valve 253 to comiect line 258 to line 221.

It will be apparent to those skilled in the art that numerous modifications andv changes may be made in the systems shown and described without departing from the invention. Among such modifications it has been foundin practice that in the embodiments shown in Figs. 1. and 4, the conductor 69 connected between rate capacitor 63 andfixed resistor 65 may be connected between slidewire 64 and fixed resistor 65. This connection is possible where the value of fixed resistor 65 is small enough so that the time required to charge capacitor, BS through resistor 65 isnot appreciably affected. Typical values v of thecomponents of this circuit in one successful embodiment were as follows:

Capacitor t3 "mid" 2e Resistor E5 ohms 15,605 Slidewire 64 do G-2OG,0O0 Slidewire 62 megohms 0450 While preferred embodiments of the invention have been illustrated and described, it is to be understood that further modifications may be made within the scope of the appended claims.

What is claimed is:

l. A balanceable control system for maintaiin ing the magnitude of a condition at a predeter mined value representing a selected control point comprising a condition-varying element, control signal responsive means for automatically operating said condition-varying element in a direction to maintain said condition at said predetei mined "value, means operable in response to changes in the magnitude of said condition to produce a first control signal, storage capacity means for modifying the operation of said signalresponsive means in accordance with a time time tion of the departure of said condition from said control point, manual means for controlling said condition-varying element, and means for trans ferring control of said condition-varying elemen' between said signal responsive means and said manual means, said control transferring means including means for continuously applying to said capacity means during manual control at least a first control quantity variable in response to said first control signal in avoidance of abrupt do partures in the position of said condition-varying element upon return of control to said signalresponsive means.

2. A balanceable control system for maintaining the magnitude of a condition at a predetermined value representing a selected control point comprising a condition-varying element, control signal responsive means for automatically operating said condition-varying element in a direction to maintain said condition at said predetermined value, means operable in response to changes in the magnitude of said condition to produce a first control signal, storage capacity means for modifying the operation of said signal-responsive means in accordance with a time function of the departure of said condition from said control point, manual means for controlling said oondition-varying element, and means for transferring control of said conditionvarying element between said signal responsive means and said manual means, said control transferring means including means for continuously and simultaneously applying to said capacity means during manual control a first control quantity variable in response to said first control signal and a second control quantity variable in response to movement of said condition-varying element in avoidance of abrupt departures in the position of said conditionvarying element upon return of control to said signal-responsive means.

3. In a control system having an amplifier responsive to changes in an electrical quantity applied to its input terminals for controlling the adjustment of a compensating means upon deviation of a condition under control, the combination comprising a first source of voltage adjustable in response to deviation of said condition under control from a predetermined value to produce a first electrical quantity, a second source of voltage adjustable with adjustment of said compensating means, a resistor-capacitor network connected to said second source of vo1tage for developing a second electrical quantity, means for connecting one output terminal of said network to an input terminal of said amplifier and the other output terminal of said network to an output terminal of said first source of voltage, and circuit-controlling means for selectively interconnecting the other output terminal of said first source of voltage to the other terminal of said amplifier for automatic control of said compensating means thereby and to the first-nan1ed input terminal of said amplifier to apply said first electrical quantity to a capacitor of said network when said compensating means is controlled by means other than by said amplifier.

4. The combination as set forth in claim 3 inv which said network includes a reset resistor and a reset capacitor.

5. The combination as set forth in claim 3 in a which said network includes a rate resistor and. a rate capacitor.

6. The combination as set forth in claim 3 in which said network includes a reset resistor, a. reset capacitor, a rate capacitor and a rate resistor and said circuit-controlling means includes switch means operative to short-circuit said rate 1; resistor when said first source of voltage is connected to said network.

7. A control system. having an amplifier to the input circuit of which there is applied an electrical potential, said control system being characterized by the provision of a reset resistor connected to said input circuit for developing another electrical potential opposing the firstnamed potential, a source of voltage adjustable, in accordance with change in the output of said amplifier, a circuit between said reset resistor and said source of voltage including a path havs ing therein a reset capacitor, and circuit-controlling means for simultaneously short-circuiti. ing the input of said amplifier and connecting; said first and second electrical potentials across said reset resistor to maintain the voltage across said reset capacitor at a value such that upon operation of said circuit-controlling means to its original position, the algebraic sum of said first and, second electrical potentials in the input ciri cuit of said amplifier is substantially zero.

8. A system for transferring between automatic and. manual adjustment of a compensating means with minimum disturbance of the compensating means upon return from manual control to autoi matic control comprising an amplifier responsive to the diiferences between two electrical signals, one of which varies in response to deviations of a variable characteristic from a control point. and the other of which varies in accordance with, the output of a resistance-capacitance network.. said network being connected across an adjust-- able source of voltage variable in response to, adjustment of said compensating means, and air-- cuit-controlling means for selectively connecting said one electrical signal to one terminal of said. amplifier for automatic control of said compen sating means or to an output terminal of said. network during manual control of said compensating means so that said capacitance has applied. thereto during manual control of said compensat-- ing means at least said one electrical signal.

9. A system in accordance with claim 8 in: which said network includesa reset resistance; and a reset capacitance.

10. A system in accordance with claim 8 in;

- which said 3 network 'includes a rate resistance and a rate capacitance.

11. A system in accordance with claim 8 .in which said network includes a reset resistance, a reset capacitance a rate resistance and a rate capacitance, and-said circuit-controlling means includesmeans for short circuiting-said rate resistance during==man-ual operationof said com pensating means.

12. In asystem "for automatically adjusting a compensatingmeans-in a-direction to return the magnitude of'a'variable characteristic toward a controlpointupon deviation therefrom,

the-combination comprising an amplifier responsive to the; difierence' between two potential differences aneans for varying-the first of said potential difierences in accordance with deviation'ofsaid characteristic fromithe control oint, a source of-voltage-variable upon change in adjustment-of saidcompensating means, a resistance-capacitancenetwork for developing said second potentialdifference connected in circuit with'saidsource oi 'voltage said network including a reset capacitor and a reset resistance, operating means for adjusting said compensating means in accordance-with the output of said amplifier,-'first circuit-controlling means for applyingboth of said-potential difierences to said reset capacitor-during operation of said compensating ezrminimum disturbance ,.-of said compensating means.

1* 13., In a balanceable control system of the type in cludinga first network having a circuit, element adjustable to produce a signal in accordance with the magnitude of a condition, a second network including an adjustable circuit element,

condition-varying means operable in response to the unbalance between said networks for varying the magnitude of said condition to maintain it at a redetermined value, a connection between said condition-varying means and said adjustable element of said second network for operating it in a system-balancing direction, said second network including a reset resistor, a reset capacitor, a rate capacitor and a rate resistor, an output circuit connected between the end of the rate resistor adjacent said rate capacitor and an output terminal of said first network, a connector extending from the other output terminal of said first network to the opposite side of said rate capacitor, means connected to said output circuit and to said condition-varying means for controlling the latter in accordance with signals applied to said output circuit, means for preventing operation of said last-named means comprising a circuit controller for connecting said rate capacitor and said reset resistor directly across said output terminals of said first network, said rate capacitor then having applied to it at all times a voltage corresponding to the signal produced in said first network whereby upon operation of said circuit controller to its original position the voltage of said rate capacitor produces a signal equal and opposite to said signal of said first network to prevent adjustment of said condition-varying means until after the voltage on said rate capacitor deviates from a value equal i tween said networks for varying the magnitude adjustable circuit element,

to the unbalancev voltage which existed across the 14. Ina balanceable control system of the type comprisinga first network including a circuit element adjustable to unbalance its networklin 1 accordance with change in the magnitude of a condition, a second network including an condition-varying means operable in response-to theunbalanceibeof said condition to maintain it at a'predetermined value, a connection between said condition-varying means and said adjustable element or" said second network for operating it in a sysseries across said reset resistor, an output circuit connected between: the end of the rate resistor adjacent said rate capacitor and anoutputterminal of said firstnetwork, a connector extending from the other output terminal of said first network to the other side of said rate capacitor, amplifier means having an input .circuit.;- connectedto said output circuitror controlling said condition-varyingmeans in accordance with'signals applied to said input circuit, means, for preventing operation of said amplifier means and said condition-varying means in, response thereto comprising a circuit controller for connectingone side of said reset capacitor :directly it at all times a voltage corresponding to the unbalance voltage of said firstnetwork so that upon operation of said circuit controller to its original positionthe voltage at the output terminals of said second network is equal and oppositeto the voltage at the output terminals of said first network to, prevent adjustment of said conditionvarying means until after the voltage across said reset capacitor deviates from a value equal to the voltage which existed across said output terminals of said first network at the time of operation of said circuit controller.

15. A balanceable control system for maintaining the magnitude of a condition at a predetermined value representing a selected control point comprising a condition-varying element, a control signal responsive means for automatically operating said condition-varying element in a direction to maintain said condition at said predetermined value, a first means operable in response to changes in the magnitude of said condition to produce a first control signal, storage capacity means for modifying the operation of said signal responsive means in accordance with a time function of the departure of said condition from said control point, a second means for operating said condition-varying element independently of change in magnitude of said first control signal, transfer means for transferring control of said condition-varying element between said first means and said second means, and means operable under the control of said transfer means for applying to said capacity means at least a control quantity of magnitude dependent upon that of said first control signal to predetermine the effectiveness of said capacity means in modifying the operation of said signal responsive means upon return of control to said first means.

16. In a system for automatically adjusting a compensating means in a direction to return the magnitude of a variable characteristic toward a control point upon deviation therefrom, the combination comprising an amplifier responsive to the difference between two potential differences, means for varying the first of said potential differences in accordance with deviation of said characteristic from said control point, a source of voltage variable upon change in adjustment of said compensating means, a resistance-capacitance network for developing said second potential difference connected in circuit with said source of voltage, said network including a reset capacitor and a reset resistance, operating means for adjusting said compensating means in accordance with the output of said amplifier, means for controlling the operation of said operating means, transfer means for placing said operating means under the control of said controlling means for adjustment of said compensating means independently of the magnitude of said first potential difference, said transfer means including circuit controllers for applying both of said potential differences to said reset capacitor, prior to operation of said transfer means to return the control of said operating means in ac cordance with said first potential difference, initially to minimize the adjustment of said compensating means as a result of the operation of said transfer means.

17. In a balanceable control system of the type comprising a first network including a circuit element adjustable to unbalance its network in accordance with change in the magnitude of a condition, a second network including an adjustable circuit element, condition-varying means operable in response to the unbalance between said networks for varying the magnitude of said condition to maintain it at a predetermined value, a connection between said condition-varying means and said adjustable element of said second network for operating it in a system-balancing direction, said second network including a reset resistor and a reset capacitor, a rate capacitor and a rate resistor connected in series across said reset resistor, an output circuit connected between the end of the rate resistor adjacent said rate capacitor and an output terminal of said first network, a conductor extending from the other output terminal of said first network to the other side of said rate capacitor, amplifier means having an input circuit connected to said output circuit for controlling said conditionvarying means in accordance with signals applied to said input circuit, means for controlling operation of said condition-varying means independently of said output circuit, means for transferring operation of said condition-varying means from said output circuit to said control means including a circuit controller which connects one side of said reset capacitor directly to one of said output terminals of said first network prior to the operation of said transfer means to restore operation of said conditionvarying means under the control of said output circuit, said reset capacitor before said restoration having applied to it a voltage including the unbalance voltage of said first network so that upon operation of said circuit controller to its original position the voltage at the output terminals of said second network is equal and opposite to the voltage at the output terminals of said first network to prevent adjustment of said condition-varying means until the voltage across said reset capacitor is changed.

References Cited in the file of this patent UNITED STATES PATENTS Number Name Date 2,175,985 Callender et a1 Oct. 10, 1939 2,429,642 Newton Oct. 28, 1947 2,621,315 Cuckler Dec. 9, 1952 2,644,642 Smoot July 7, 1953 

